On my way home from Ellie's six-month pediatrician's visit this afternoon, I was stopped at a red light trying to air out my sweaty gas pedal foot when a man knocked on the window. Surprised out of my weird little reverie, I rolled the window down a crack.
"Don't be scared," he said. "I don't look homeless, right?" He was missing most of his teeth, so he in fact did look like he could be homeless, but who am I to judge? "Uh, no." I faltered. He thanked me for smiling (apparently nobody else he'd approached had) and told me that his car--he pointed to my right across the lanes of traffic--was broken down and he just needed four more dollars to get it fixed.
Stop right here. You know where this is going, right?
I've lived in Austin, New York, and London and heard versions of this story a million times: "My daughter is in the hospital and I need two--no, three--more dollars for cab fare," "Somebody stole my wallet and I just need 5 pounds to get something to eat." "I'm trying to get to Florida to see my family and I need ten more dollars for bus fare." Or my very favorite, in the 14th Street subway station in New York: "Can I have some money for Starbucks? $5 would do it."
I usually approach these situations by making a compromise with them. Listen, I'm no fool--I know they are likely lying (except the Starbucks guy. Even if that was a lie, it was a good one)--and I know they approach me because I am (or look) young, am female, and it's true, I smile a lot. I'm an easy target. But what if they are telling the truth? What if their daughter really were in the hospital and my money would get them that much closer to where they need to be? Or let's face it, if they just really, really, need a beer or some other quick fix? What if I were in that situation and nobody believed me? So what I normally do is offer up a dollar, two at most. I consider this to be a fair deal--I can afford to part with the occasional dollar--and if they are lying, it's no skin off my teeth. Whatever the truth of their situation is, it's not easy having no money.
But today I let myself get taken advantage of.
"I just need $4. I can give you change for a five," he said. When I opened my wallet, he peered in through the window and saw my two 10-dollar bills and a one. "I only need eight," he said as I removed the $1 bill. "If you give me ten, I can give you $3 back." (I know, none of this was making any sense.) I was put on the spot, the light had changed to green, and I had the baby--grumpy from her vaccinations--in the back seat. I handed him the ten. "How can I get this money back to you?" he asked, handing me a pocketful of change that included two quarters, four dimes, and several pennies, including a Canadian penny. "Don't worry about it," I answered predictably, as he headed away from where his car was supposed to parked. An (I assume empty) laptop bag banged against his hip as he walked.
And I don't know why, but the whole interaction made me feel terrible. I am actually OK with being kind of gullible (or at least people assuming that I am)--I never want to be somebody who is rude or spiteful toward the homeless or anybody else when a simple "no, thank you" or "sorry, I don't have it" will do. One of the saddest things I saw in New York was a man carrying several large black trash bags worth of stuff and smelling of dirt riding the train during rush hour one morning. The only free seat in the entire car was the one next to him and person after person (including myself, although I had gotten on before the train was full and sat down across from him) raced to that seat and then, realizing who was sitting there, quickly veered away. For most the trip he appeared to be asleep and unaware of what was going on around him, but at one point he looked over just as a man in a suit made the same mistake all the previous riders had made. And the homeless man--an older guy, possibly somebody's grandfather--looked so very hurt by it that it makes me unbearably sad even thinking about it now. I spent the rest of the ride impotently wondering if I should go and sit beside him myself, but he had closed his eyes again and I never could work up the nerve.
But back to today's state of affairs. I think what depressed me so much about it is that dishonesty lay at the heart of the transaction. It's not so much that I'm upset over being separated from my 10-dollar bill--though it does sting a little--but if I had called it for what it was and parted with $1 instead (all I had to say was "I'm sorry, $1 is all I can spare." I've said it countless times before), I would have felt like the playing field was closer to even. Instead I was left with a feeling like the man left thinking, "Ha! She bought it." It was unfair.
Part of what was different about today was that I was in a car. Other than the occasional forced window washing, all of my transactions with those asking for money have been on foot or on a train. The car somehow changed that dynamic, though I suppose next time I will be more prepared. Not that it's any of my business, but I do hope that the guy uses the $10 to buy a meal or something. But if he just needs a quick fix (whatever that fix may be), well, then that's his business as well. I continued home to my comfortable house with my beautiful, healthy infant daughter and was greeted by two dogs who probably eat more regularly (or at least get better dental care) than this man. Take that for what you will.
Recent Comments